Arizona Reports Anti-Semitic Incidents: Anti-Defamation League

ACROSS ARIZONA—The Anti-Defamation League reported anti-Semitic incidents occurred last year in almost every state, including 20 in Arizona.

Anti-Semitic incidents reported in 2019 spiked to the highest level in at least 40 years, with a record 2,100 acts of assault, vandalism and harassment against Jews reported across the United States, including in Arizona, according to a report released Tuesday by the Anti-Defamation League.

Anti-Semitic incidents increased 12 percent in 2019 from the prior year, including a 56 percent increase in the number of assaults against Jews — more than half of them occurring in New York City, the report said. All U.S. states except Alaska and Hawaii reported at least one anti-Semitic incident last year.

The report “speaks to the lived experience of Jewish people in the United States,” Aryeh Tuchman, the associate director of the Anti-Defamation League’s Center on Extremism, told Patch.

The 2,107 incidents of anti-Semitic incidents “don’t mean that every Jewish person needs to look over their shoulder all the time,” Tuchman said. “In terms of victims affected directly, that’s a very small percentage of the population. But at the same time, because of reporting, social media and word of mouth, that can have an outside impact on the sense of security, sense of confidence and the possible fear of American Jews.”

The audit includes both criminal and non-criminal acts of intimidation and harassment. In the 61 assault incidents, 95 people were harmed and five were killed. Those attacks included the 2019 shooting at Chabad of Poway in California, where one person was killed; the shooting at kosher grocery store in New Jersey, where six people, including three Jews, were killed; and a stabbing during a Hanukkah celebration in which one person died of his injuries and several others were wounded.

The assaults also included “the really concerning state of violent attacks on Jews that took place in Brooklyn at the end of the year,” Tuchman said.

In general, “the assaults we documented in 2019 ranged from confrontations not involving weapons — pushing, punching and throwing of objects with evidence of anti-Semitic intent — to the really alarming deadly use of weapons, such as guns and knives,” Tuchman said.

On average, there were as many as six anti-Semitic incidents in the United States each day in 2019, the highest level of anti-Semitic activity since the Anti-Defamation League began collecting statistics in 1979.

The Anti-Defamation League report showed 1,127 harassment incidents, 919 vandalism incidents and 61 assault incidents. The five states with the highest number of anti-Semitic reports were:

1. New York, 430
2. New Jersey, 345
3. California,330
4. Massachusetts, 114
5. Pennsylvania, 109

Combined, those states had 45 percent of the total number of anti-Semitic incidents last year in the United States. More than half of the assaults nationwide occurred in the five boroughs of New York City, including 25 in Brooklyn alone, the report said.

In Arizona, incidents included:

• Anti-Semitic Incident - Harassment, White Supremacist Propaganda

On Nov. 4, 2019 in Tempe, Folks Front, a white supremacist, distributed propaganda at Arizona State University that read: "Love not hate" with the "o" in Love depicted as a swastika and the "a" in hate depicted as a Jewish star.

• Anti-Semitic Incident - Harassment

In October 2019 in Phoenix, an Instagram account was created in order to harass a Jewish boy.

• Anti-Semitic Incident - Assault

In September 2019 in Phoenix, a Jewish man and his two children were walking home from synagogue when two people in a car veered toward the Jewish pedestrians, yelled something and through a glass bottle at them.

• Anti-Semitic Incident - Vandalism

In September 2019 in Tucson, drawings of swastikas, guns, and nooses were found on bathroom walls in a high school.

• Anti-Semitic Incident - Vandalism

In May 2019 in Tucson, a swastika was carved into a picnic table at a park.

The report does not draw conclusions about the motivation behind the anti-Semitic incidents. Tuchman said it’s important not to generalize.

“Every case needs to be assessed on its own,” he said. “When we know who perpetuated a particular assault, we need to understand the motivation of that perpetrator may not be what motivated another perpetrator.”

Typically, he said, the number of assaults in a given year range from 30 to 60, and 2019 is “the latest high-mark year.” Because the number of American Jews reporting anti-Semitic incidents is relatively small, “it’s harder to extrapolate broader trends,” he said.

In an earlier report, the Anti-Defamation League reported an uptick in extremism at stay-at-home protests urging governors to reopen states for business after coronavirus-related closures, but Tuchman said anti-Semitism isn’t an overarching theme.

“It’s a very, very small number of people at these rallies who exhibit bad behavior related to ideological extremism, let alone anti-Semitism,” he said. He pointed out that the presence of swastikas on some signs is more a condemnation of governors’ stay-home orders than anti-Jewish sentiment.

“We view that as offensive,” Tuchman said, “but not necessarily anti-Semitic.”

He said extremists find anti-government activity generally “very attractive, so it’s not surprising a small number were able to glob on to these protests.”

“The message we need to convey is that, obviously, we live in a world, as these incidents point out, where you have to take appropriate security measures to take care of yourselves and your family,” Tuchman said. “American Jews should not be intimidated by them. American Jews are proud and secure in our country and should not let these anti-Semitic incidents shake that pride in their identity.”

The report also “underscores the fact that in order to fight hatred and anti-Semitism, it’s very important to measure it and understand not through anecdote and impressionist accounts, but rather through hard data and evidence.”

Anti-Semitic incidents may be reported on the organization’s website.

The report doesn’t cover 2020 anti-Semitic incidents, but the Anti-Defamation League keeps a running count as they are reported. In Arizona this year, incidents include:

• Anti-Semitic Incident - Harassment

In March 2020 in Phoenix, a white supremacist unveiled a Nazi flag at a campaign event for Democratic presidential candidate Senator Bernie Sanders.

• Anti-Semitic Incident - Vandalism

In February 2020 in Scottsdale, a shopping center was defaced with swastika graffiti.

• Anti-Semitic Incident - Vandalism

In February 2020 in Tucson, an exhibit at the Holocaust History Center in Tucson was defaced with graffiti that read, "Hail Hitler."

Don't miss local and statewide news about coronavirus developments and precautions. Sign up for Patch alerts and daily newsletters. Also, for updated coverage on national news surrounding coronavirus, sign up for the Patch Across America daily newsletter.