MA Schools Ranked By Equity: Worcester Near Bottom

WORCESTER, MA — A new ranking attempts to evaluate equity in school districts across Massachusetts by comparing per-pupil spending to local income.

The ranking, created by the personal finance website WalletHub, probes whether wealthier school districts are spending more money per student than poorer districts. Wealthier towns, including Dover, Weston, Wellesley and Wayland, all appeared near the bottom of the ranking.

But some poorer districts, like Chelsea and Worcester, also ranked low on the list due to a combination of below-average per-student spending and low household income.

To create the list, WalletHub looked at the average household income and the average per-pupil expenditure in each school district. Each district was given a base score of 50 points. For each 1 percent above the state average per-pupil spend, one point was deducted from the base score. One point was added for each 1 percent above the state's average median income.

Statewide, the average per-pupil spend was about $16,500 as of December, according to the state Department of Education. The state calculates the per-pupil spend by dividing a district's budget by the number of full-time enrolled students. The median household income in Massachusetts is about $77,378, according to the U.S. Census Bureau.

The most equitable district in the state, the North Shore's Pentucket Regional School District, had a per-pupil spend of $15,791 and a median income of $100,785. Dover Public Schools came in last with a per-pupil spend of $21,900 and median income at $224,784.

There are other measures to assess equity in Massachusetts schools.

The state DOE equity plan focuses on reducing teacher turnover, and training newer teachers. According to the state, low-income students have nearly double the rate of first-year teachers as high income students. Poorer students also have a higher rate of teachers rated as "needs improvement/unsatisfactory."

Equity is at the forefront of education discussions due to the coronavirus pandemic. Issues like food insecurity, special education, and access to technology have all been exacerbated by the pandemic, according to the Massachusetts Education Equity Partnership. School districts with less money may have trouble providing adequate education to students who are learning remotely either full or part-time.

Here's a look at where local school districts ranked on WalletHub's list (rankings are overall in the state):

• No. 25 Framingham, $19,141 per-student with a $79,136 median household income
• No. 73 Marlborough, $17,738 per-student with a $79,228 median household income
• No. 77 Natick, $16,354 per-student with a $109,490 median household income
• No. 123 Milford, $15,594 per-student with an $82,129 median household income
• No. 253 Worcester, $15,373 per-student with a $46,407 median household income
• No. 278 Sudbury, $17,132 per-student with a $176,570 median household income
• No. 279 Lincoln-Sudbury Regional High School, $20,005 per-student with a $163,523 median household income
• No. 283 Wayland, $19,657 per-student with a $174,330 median household income