North Hills Pizza: Who Makes The Best?

ROSS TOWNSHIP, PA - No matter how you slice it, there’s no disputing this fact about pizza: People like different types of pie, so trying to determine an area’s best pizza places is a virtual impossibility; it’s a matter of personal preference.

That being said, some pizza places in the North Hills appear to be preferred by more people than others, at least when it comes to Google reviews. What follows is a ranking of the North Hills’ top pizza joints based on the average number of stars received in reviews.

Agree or disagree with the findings? Leave your thoughts in the comments section below.

4.6 stars

• Sir Pizza, Sewickley-Oakmont & Rochester roads, Ross

Wrote one reviewer: “They have the best sauce I have ever eaten. I love the small square slices and the corner slice or their pepperoni sausage pizza is the best single slice of pizza in the world.”

• Adrian’s, 7824 Old Perry Highway, McCandless

“The crust is crispy on the outside and the sauce and cheese are tasty,” gushed one Adrian’s enthusiast.

4.5 stars

• Large Plain, 3286 Babcock Boulevard, Ross “Price is right,” one person opined. “Pizza tastes great. It’s not greasy.”

4.4 stars

• Luciano’s, Pizza & Six Pack To Go, 1411 Duncan Ave., McCandless

“Their pizza with red sauce is outstanding, but nothing compares to their white pizza...NOTHING,” one review stated emphatically. “The freshness of the ingredients and the taste of the crust is just outstanding.”

• Center Avenue Slice, 332 Center Ave., West View

“Center Avenue Slice is my favorite pizza place in the North Hills,” a reviewer wrote.”Whenever friends come in from out of town they always want to order Center Avenue Slice.”

4.2 stars

• Vocelli Pizza, 1130 Perry Highway, Ross

Yes, it’s a chain but chains have lots of fans. That’s how they got to be chains, right? Raved one reviewer: “They have a pizza counter set up similar to Subway where you pick your sauces, toppings, cheeses and more. The options are endless. Friendly staff and clean establishment.”

• Maisie’s Pizza, Pines Plaza, McCandless

“I eat there alot and never get sick of it,” a regular offered. “Buffalo chicken pizza is awesome and not too spicy.”

• BJ’s Restaurant and Brewhouse, 8970 Covenant Road, McCandless

While we couldn’t find a review specific to the pizza, this place apparently has a huge menu and is always busy - both good signs.

4.1 stars

• Pelegrino’s Pizza & Pasta, 4846 McKnight Road, Ross

“We had the pepperoni rolls (8 large ones) and the hand-tossed Pelegrino specialty pizza,” one fan wrote. :They have yummy sauce and dough! Highly recommended!”

Photo via Shutterstock.

Subscribe to North Hills Patch for more local news and real-time alerts.